A member of the Pakistan Rangers, a paramilitary law enforcement organization with a long and troubled history in Karachi. My data show that the Rangers command more public trust than the police, and are credited for reducing violent crime and militancy in the city. Nevertheless, many communities still remember suffering rights violations at the hands of the force — especially during “Operation Clean-Up” in the 1990s. This photo was taken from the adjoining car, and I was careful not to capture the ranger’s full face.